Skip to content

Choosing an HRMS for a company of 10 to 100 employees

How to pick HRMS and payroll software when you have 10 to 100 people: what to require, what to skip, pricing models to watch for and questions to ask every vendor.

Saralix Team4 min read
On this page

A company of ten people can run payroll in a spreadsheet. A company of a hundred cannot, not safely. Somewhere between those numbers, the spreadsheet starts to cost more than software: in errors, in late filings, in hours, and in the awkward conversations that follow a wrong payslip. This guide is for the person who has been asked to find a replacement, probably without a big budget and without a dedicated IT team.

We build an HRMS, so we have a view. We have tried to write this so it is useful whichever product you end up with.

Start with the problem, not the feature list

Vendors will show you forty modules. Your decision should come from the three or four things that hurt today. Write them down before any demo. For most companies in this size range they are:

  1. Payroll accuracy and statutory compliance. PF, ESI, professional tax by state, TDS and the filings that follow.
  2. Attendance and leave feeding payroll. Without this, someone retypes data every month.
  3. Employee records and documents. Onboarding, letters and a single source of truth.
  4. Employee self-service. Payslips, leave and tax forms without messaging HR.

Everything else, such as performance reviews, recruitment and learning, is useful, but is not usually why you need to change tools. Treat them as extras.

What to require

Indian statutory depth

If you operate in India, generic global HR tools usually lack the details that matter. Ask the vendor to show, not describe:

  • PF with the wage ceiling, the EPF and EPS split and the ECR file in the current format.
  • ESI with the contribution ceiling and the half-yearly period behaviour.
  • Professional tax slabs for each state you hire in.
  • TDS under both the old and new regimes, with declarations and proofs.
  • Form 16 and 24Q data.
  • Gratuity and full and final settlement.

Ask which rates were last updated and how updates are communicated.

Controls

Small companies are not exempt from fraud and error. Ask about:

  • Maker-checker approval on payroll.
  • Role-based access, so a manager sees their team and not everyone’s pay.
  • An audit log that records who changed what.
  • Two-factor sign-in.
  • How bank account numbers are stored.

A clean way in and out

Moving to a new system should not be a one-way door. Ask how you import employees and history, whether there is a dry run, and how you export your data if you leave.

What you can skip at this size

  • Complicated workflow builders. At 50 people, a simple approval chain is enough.
  • AI features as a deciding factor. Check that the fundamentals are right first.
  • A long integration list. You need your bank file format, your accounting export and a way to import attendance. Beyond that, check what you actually use.

Understand the pricing model

Software pricing in this segment usually falls into one of these shapes:

  • Per employee per month, often with a minimum number of employees. Easy to forecast, grows as you do.
  • Tiered bands, where the price per employee falls as headcount rises.
  • Per module, where payroll, attendance and the rest are priced separately. Read the total, not the first number.
  • Setup or implementation fees, sometimes large.
  • Free tiers, which can be genuine for very small teams but may limit users, features or support.

Ask: what is my bill at my headcount today, and at double? Which features are not included? Is there a fee for additional admin users? What happens to the price when I cross a band?

A short evaluation process

  1. Write requirements from the pain points above, ranked.
  2. Shortlist three vendors. More than three means you will not evaluate any properly.
  3. Give each the same scenario. Use one real pay structure with an allowance, a joiner mid-month, one person on LOP and one with a reimbursement. Ask each vendor to run it.
  4. Check the outputs by hand against your own calculation, including PF, ESI, PT and TDS.
  5. Talk to a customer of similar size. If the vendor has none to offer, that is information.
  6. Run a parallel payroll for one month, in the new system and your old method, before switching.
  7. Check support. Send a real question during your evaluation and see how fast and how well it is answered.

Red flags

  • The vendor cannot show a statutory file such as ECR in the current format.
  • Pricing is hidden until after a sales call, and then changes with each call.
  • Payroll can be edited after approval with no record.
  • No dry run for imports.
  • Claims about customers, certifications or awards without anything you can verify.
  • Reluctance to explain what the product does not do.

Questions to ask every vendor

  1. Which statutory rules were last updated, and when?
  2. How do you handle a state-specific professional tax change?
  3. Can payroll be approved by someone other than the preparer?
  4. Where is our data stored, and who can access it?
  5. How do I export all my data?
  6. What is the total price at my headcount, with every extra I will need?
  7. What happens if I grow past 100 employees?

Where Saralix fits

Saralix is built for the 10-to-100 range and beyond, with payroll, compliance, attendance and leave, self-service and the controls above. It is free for up to 10 employees with one admin user, and Rs 99 per employee per month for 11 to 100 employees, plus GST, with all modules included. Above 100 employees, pricing is a contract rate. We are an early-stage product, so if you try us, you will talk directly to the people building it.

Whichever product you choose, make the decision on a real payroll scenario, not on a slide deck. A good system will survive that test, and you will learn more in one parallel run than in ten demos.

Free up to 10 employees

Run your first payroll free.

Attendance, leave, payroll and PF, ESI, PT and TDS compliance in one place. See the plans, or ask for a walkthrough.